{rfName}
Ef

Licencia y uso

Icono OpenAccess

Altmetrics

Investigadores/as Institucionales

Rivera-Alvarez, AraceliAutor o Coautor

Compartir

22 de octubre de 2024
Publicaciones
>
Artículo

Efficacy of the Otago-Exercise-Programme to reduce falls in community-dwelling adults aged 65-80 when delivered as group or individual training: Non-inferiority-clinical-trial

Publicado en: Bmc Nursing. 23 (1): 705- - 2024-10-01 23(1), DOI: 10.1186/s12912-024-02310-3

Autores:

Albornos-Munoz, Laura; Blanco-Blanco, Joan; Cidoncha-Moreno, Maria Angeles; Abad-Corpa, Eva; Rivera-Alvarez, Araceli; Lopez-Pisa, Rosa Maria; Caperos, Jose Manuel; Moreno-Casbas, Maria Teresa
[+]

Afiliaciones

Abrantes Primary Healthcare Ctr, Direcc Asistencial Ctr, Madrid, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Acad Nursing Sci Bizkaia, Primary Care & Prevent & Hlth Promot RICAPPS, Bilbao, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Basque Hlth Serv, Gen Head Off Osakidetza Subdirect Nursing, Vitoria, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Bioaraba Hlth Res Inst, Vitoria, Spain - Autor o Coautor
GRECS Biomed Res Inst Lleida IRB Lleida, Hlth Care Res Grp, Lleida, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Inst Catala Salut, Barcelona, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Inst Salud Carlos III, Biomed Res Network Ctr Frailty & Hlth Aging CIBERF, Nursing & Hlth Care Res Unit Investen Isciii, Madrid, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Inst Salud Carlos III, Res Network Chron, Nursing & Hlth Care Res Unit Investen ISCIII, Primary Care & Prevent & Hlth Promot RICAPPS, Madrid, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Pontif Comillas Univ, Dept Psychol, Madrid, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Univ Lleida, Dept Nursing & Physiotherapy, Comprehens Care & Hlth Serv Programme, Lleida, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Univ Lleida, GRECS Biomed Res Inst Lleida IRB Lleida, Biomed Res Network Ctr Frailty & Hlth Aging CIBERF, Dept Nursing & Physiotherapy, Lleida, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Univ Murcia SMS, Biomed Res Network Ctr Frailty & Hlth Aging CIBERF, Investen Isciii, IMIB Arrixaca, Murcia, Spain - Autor o Coautor
Ver más

Resumen

BackgroundThe Otago Exercise Programme is an effective intervention for falls prevention. However, there is limited evidence in relation to studies that compare efficacy for falls prevention when delivered Otago Exercise Programme in a group or individual format in a primary care context.ObjectiveTo compare the Otago Exercise Programme delivered as a group vs. individual format for community dwelling older adults, over a one year period. The hypothesis was that neither format would be inferior to the other.Design:A four-year multicentre, randomized, non-inferiority clinical trial, with two arms- Otago Exercise Programme group training and individual Otago exercise training. Setting(s): 21 primary healthcare centers. Participants: A sample size of 728 participants was established. Participants were aged between 65 and 80 years; living in the community; able to walk independently; and agreed to take part in the study and provided signed informed consent. Intervention: The Otago Exercise Programme was delivered mainly by nurses in primary care, with five face to face sessions, and a reinforcement 6 months later. Participants were encouraged to exercise at home between face to face sessions. Data collection: at baseline and after 6 and 12 months from October 2017 to 2020. Primary outcome: people who reported at least one fall. Secondary outcomes: number of falls, cause of falls, consequences and assistance, adherence and satisfaction. Group allocation was blinded to the researchers involved in analysis. Reporting: Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials recommendations for the Statement for Randomized Trials of Nonpharmacologic Treatments.ResultsEight hundred twenty-seven participants were randomized (226 were allocated in group training and 272 in individual training). The analysis of the proportion of people who reported at least one fall and number of falls showed no differences between individual and group training. Assessment of the equivalence between the interventions at 12 months showed that the confidence interval for the difference of people who reported at least one fall was found to be within the equivalence limit of 10% considered. However, in those participants with a previous history of falls, group format showed potentially greater benefit. The participants in individual training presented higher scores on the Exercise Adherence Rating Scale test. No differences were found in satisfaction between the groups.ConclusionsThe group Otago Exercise Programme is equivalent to individually delivered Otago Exercise Programme in terms of prevention of falls over a 12-month follow up. Adherence was higher in individual training. Implications: Healthcare professionals could offer either Otago Exercise Programme format dependent on patient preference and be confident that that standardized intervention provides patient benefit.Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov (NCT03320668). Data registration 31/10/2017.
[+]

Palabras clave

Accidental fallsClinical trialConfidence-intervalsEconomic-evaluationExercise therapyHome-based exerciseOlder-peopleOtago exercise programmOtago exercise programmeParticipatioPrevent fallsPrimary careRandomized controlled-trial

Indicios de calidad

Impacto bibliométrico. Análisis de la aportación y canal de difusión

El trabajo ha sido publicado en la revista BMC Nursing debido a la progresión y el buen impacto que ha alcanzado en los últimos años, según la agencia WoS (JCR), se ha convertido en una referencia en su campo. En el año de publicación del trabajo, 2024 aún no existen indicios calculados, pero en 2023, se encontraba en la posición 9/193, consiguiendo con ello situarse como revista Q1 (Primer Cuartil), en la categoría Nursing. Destacable, igualmente, el hecho de que la Revista está posicionada por encima del Percentil 90.

Independientemente del impacto esperado determinado por el canal de difusión, es importante destacar el impacto real observado de la propia aportación.

Según las diferentes agencias de indexación, el número de citas acumuladas por esta publicación hasta la fecha 2026-04-04:

  • WoS: 6
  • Scopus: 6
  • Europe PMC: 5
[+]

Impacto y visibilidad social

Desde la dimensión de Influencia o adopción social, y tomando como base las métricas asociadas a las menciones e interacciones proporcionadas por agencias especializadas en el cálculo de las denominadas “Métricas Alternativas o Sociales”, podemos destacar a fecha 2026-04-04:

  • La utilización de esta aportación en marcadores, bifurcaciones de código, añadidos a listas de favoritos para una lectura recurrente, así como visualizaciones generales, indica que alguien está usando la publicación como base de su trabajo actual. Esto puede ser un indicador destacado de futuras citas más formales y académicas. Tal afirmación es avalada por el resultado del indicador “Capture” que arroja un total de: 65 (PlumX).

Con una intencionalidad más de divulgación y orientada a audiencias más generales podemos observar otras puntuaciones más globales como:

    Es fundamental presentar evidencias que respalden la plena alineación con los principios y directrices institucionales en torno a la Ciencia Abierta y la Conservación y Difusión del Patrimonio Intelectual. Un claro ejemplo de ello es:

    • El trabajo se ha enviado a una revista cuya política editorial permite la publicación en abierto Open Access.
    [+]

    Reconocimientos ligados al ítem

    We would like to thank all the participants and healthcare professionals for taking part in this study and the Otago Project Working Group. Thank you to expert, Alba Ayala from Institute of Health Carlos III for external review.
    [+]